*this one is mine*. It is also said, We made between it (the heaven) and the earth a great expanse., Al-Jawhar said, A man became awsa, meaning a possessor of abundance and riches, and from it is the saying of the Exalted, And the Heaven, we constructed it with power, and we made it a vast expanse meaning, rich (aghniy) and powerful (qdirn). And this incorporates all the sayings., [Al-Sad]: [And verily we made it expansive] in its area and space and we are also expansive upon our servants with sustenance., [Al-Shawkn]: Al-Msi is the one possessing abundance and the meaning is we are possessors of vastness in our creation of it and other than it, we are not incapable of that. Lately scholars have adopted your quoted translation with the explanation that the earlier translators didn't know that the universe was expanding. New articles are added every week. Record your voice here for it to be aired on the Atheist Republic Voicemails Podcast. Let's see if this is really true. The Big Bang 2. 100 Years of Possibilities., was announced. Miracle: The Quran revealed the universe is expanding. Debunking: Quran 51:47 "And the heaven we constructed with strength, and indeed we are [it's] expander.". But then again why does Sura 41 describe the seven heavens within this context? It only takes a minute to sign up. This is quite simply wrong. and dense point; that exploded and brought about the beginning of the universe, The modern translation of Surat Adh-Dhriyt 51:47 reads And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. This is compared with the now known ongoing expansion of the universe. The sources are well quoted in the answer. My understanding as a lay-person, is that the Quran can be understood in different ways, when it comes to these scientific sounding verses. Well from what I do understand this meaning is not excluded, as in this verse the major meaning is to show the ability of Allah, HIS power and strength to create and expand the heaven, which indeed is a greater and more difficult construct or creation than any other of Allahs creations including mankind and earth. However, in order to avoid violating the static universe model that was prevalent at that time, Einstein put that finding aside. The third, [we are] powerful, able, said by Ibn Quaybah. My own understanding of this verse is that some kind of expansion is included in the verses, but as the translation used in the quote from qtafsir shows the salafi view is that is equal to with hands, and may create confusion, if there was not a traditional interpretation as the one of ibn 'Abbas we would have here an issue, as strength would be considered as an interpretation which is not allowed for Allah's attributes by salafi scholars. Wow! I came across an article saying how the Qu'ran contains modern science finding, and these are proof that it could not have been written by a single. L'articolo / video che hai richiesto non esiste ancora. The sprouting of a seed from Use this new password to access the site. 3$ / month : $3.00 USD - monthly7$ / month : $7.00 USD - monthly15$ / month : $15.00 USD - monthly25$ / month : $25.00 USD - monthly50$ / month : $50.00 USD - monthly100$ / month : $100.00 USD - monthly. Let me guess: Harun Yahya or Yusuf Estes (rather than the Qur'an)! First of all, the earth does wobble. Google Translateadjectiveexpanded, , , wideneddeveloped, , , , So the quranic meaning fit the three meaning..Expanding, widening and developing. With the introduction of the Big Bang theory, it soon So the creation of the heavens is a much greater and complex creation than any other creation of Allah, and Allah here gives examples of how even if this creation was that difficult, complex and great HE is able to expand and go further, this is a sign for mankind, as they can only witness the result of HIS creation without being able to observe how. The Big Bang theory and expanding universe theory are still theories. the matter in the universe came into existence from one single extremely hot Good to mention is that you will find older translations that actually translate the word to "expanding". Counterargument: False translation. Indeed the Qur'an refers to the universe has having expanded, but such hardly proposes a miraculous prediction of modern science, since such ideas flourished prior to the rise of Islam. "They will find there everything they did and your Lord will not wrong anyone at all." (Qur'an, 18:49) Allah has created everything, living or non-living, which has existed since the beginning of. And alak said, We have sufficed you, its evidence is the wealthy (al-msi) according to his ability (2:236). (Quran 6:101), Is not He who created the found. Thanks for contributing to knowledge development. Therefore other scholars say as Muslims we consider the Qur'an as true, while many scientific theories change with the time, so coupling a quranic statement with a theory is a risky matter, as if this theory would one day considered being wrong we would clearly allow the conclusion that the Qur'an is wrong too. deserves to be praised, Dua (Supplication) (part 3 of 4): Why dua remains unanswered, Dua (Supplication) (part 4 of 4): Even Prophets "Most books on witchcraft will tell you that witches work naked. Why are there so many trying to disprove some part of the Quran. However, the Big Bang was introduced as a scientific theory only in the 20th century. Perhaps the most obvious is the claim of Adam and Eve, which has been determined genetically impossible. Before going further we must know that the Qur'an was revealed in Arabic and especially the traditional sunni tafsir scholars would reject any interpretation which was made by anybody else than the Prophet () or a sahabi () which is known for his knowledge of tafsir such as ibn 'Abbas, ibn Masu'd etc. Campermon,a middle aged, middle class, Guardian reading, dad of four, knackered hippy, woolly jumper wearing wino and science teacher. At its time in Arabia, poetry to them was like Street Rap. There is absolutely nothing in this verse that suggests anything else. One of those elements is iron. Yet, due to the limitations Secondly, its not possible mountains could hold down the earth, unless you think the earth is flat. When the light an object emits is displaced toward the red end of the spectrum. The only conclusion that could be derived from a universe where everything moves away from everything else is that the universe constantly 'expands'. (51:47) Even stranger is that some Muslims have decided the word crushed implies ants are made of glass, and that recent science has discovered this to be the case. I'm already a subscriber and think you do great vids. Also, in some of the verses, they have many interpretations for 'Samaa' so you cannot be certain i guess. Yusuf Ali: With power and skill did We construct the Firmament: for it is We Who create the vastness of pace. It was recently discovered ants communicate by rubbing their bodies. Firstly, this verse is not talking about the universe; it is talking about the sky. However, he had laid his discovery to rest simply not to conflict with the widely recognized static universe model of his time. 8/4/2021. Also note that Hubble came up with the expanding universe theory in the 1920's. #1by debunkingislam Sep 19, 2010 9:52 pm, #6by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:33 pm, #8by bdcarlitosway Sep 20, 2010 4:40 pm, #10by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:48 pm, #11by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:51 pm, #17by Hajj Baba Mustafa Jan 10, 2013 11:09 pm, #19by Spearthrower Jan 11, 2013 10:10 am, #20by Just A Theory Jan 11, 2013 1:21 pm, Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 2 guests. The expansion of the universe implied that if it could travel backwards in time, the universe would prove to have originated from a single point. Al-Qutab said, We are possessors of vastness (in generosity, richness) over our creation. And the meaning is approximate. [1] The First Let's see the verse!In the meantime, let me give you some actual references. Imam at-Tabari in his tafsir quoted 6 traditional interpretations of where the meaning with strength was used and could find an explanation for any other interpretation to make it fit this (general) meaning (again referring to the verses Kilise has quoted). The Quran describes the moons light as reflected light long before it was known. What does Allah have against cobalt? @Medi1Saif Please do! According to the Sumerians, the heavens had been separated from the earth (Gilgamesh, Enkidu and the nether world) and the idea that the heavens and the earth were one single block that was broken into two was common in ancient Egypt. The most prominent minds in history kept claiming that either the universe had its limits or that it was an endless infinite space. Quran also mentioned the day of doom which implies that universe is not eternal. This is evident in other passages as well. 1000 years before Muhammad, Aristotle wrote The drinkable, sweet water, then, is light, and is all of it drawn up. General Commercial. Knowing Creator. Message to the Muslims 3: Punishment Or Respite, Gods House At Wrong Place. These facts were there to make the people at the time understand. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. However, alaq has a deeper meaning, and it's root is actually "that which clings" and it is this meaning which people take today, since it matches the reality of our observations. The Big Bang theory states that around 12-15 billion For example, Zakir Naik says, It was Edwin Hubble who discovered that the universe is expanding. Until, in 1998, the Hubble Space Telescopes observations of very distant supernovas unveiled that a long time ago, the universe was expanding more slowly than it is today. The extremely high density within the "primeval atom" would cause the universe to expand rapidly. It contains a lot of brief, yet informative articles about different aspects of Islam. But I will to keep it hidden, that every soul may be rewarded for that which it strives (to achieve)." These elements scattered when those stars exploded and later gathered together by gravity to form other stars and planets, including earth. Submitted by Lee M. on Thu, 02/21/2013 - 16:37. Most of the elements found within the earth were formed by fusion within stars of the early universe. It was already known about. I haven't viewed them yet, but that looks awesome. The Arabic word for "ostrich egg" is also a verb that means "spread", and . And we sent down iron in which there lies great force and which has many uses for mankind (Surah 57:25). Geocentric Cosmology 4. Gas is a state of matter, smoke is a collection of solids, liquids and gases that are emitted when a material combusts. As the Universe rapidly increased in size, light chemicals like hydrogen and helium began to form. How could anyone have know this 1400 years ago? the heavens and earth were created. What the scholars could explain was the Debunking: Quran 51:47 "And the heaven we constructed with strength, and indeed we are [it's] expander." Lets start by saying that no Muslim ever suggested that the universe was expanding before it was discovered by scientists, and this verse never meant 'universe is expanding' until recently. the invention of the first telescope, at a time when there was primitive knowledge And al-asan said, We expand the sustenance through rain and water. As for the statement of alIzz bin Abd al-Salm52 in his tafsr, [That we are possessors of abundance] in enlargening sustenance through rain, or the heaven, or [that] nothing that we desire is difficult for us, or [that] we [are able] to create another heaven like it, or with a greater expanse than the expanse of [this] heaven then there is no indication or proof in it to establish that the universe is expanding as alleged in the Big Bang conjecture. this is the vital point: the smoke in Sura 41: 11-12 does not apply to space but only matter, (Let me quickly summarize this, before we move on: The problem concerns the relation between Sura 79 and 41, in terms of structure and space. Instead, he added a term called the cosmological constant to his equations that would make his calculations consistent with a static universe. about the universe. Slipher, noticed that the galaxies were moving away from Random Quranic Science claims - Debunked. I have read those verses about big bang, but that was many years later when i came to live in USA then i read about dicovery of tow scientests a bout big bang( that was exactly stated in Qur'an). We can use other verses from the Quran to understand what meaning is intended here. Perhaps that is why it seems Islam is so new to apologetics. It doesnt contain calculus equations or engineering instructions for rocket propulsion. January 13, 2021. The preceding verses mention numerous events involving Allah. Secondly, it makes no sense to suggest it means God is expanding the universe after the verse has just said God has built (past tense) the sky and since the universe was already expanding nine billion years before the sky was formed. Allah constructed it. many people in his time, Prophet Muhammad happened to be illiterate and simply Message To Muslims: Come That We Burn All Books Written By All Saints Of Your Sects And Start A New Life. Embedded hyperlinks in a thesis or research paper, tar command with and without --absolute-names option. I find this all very interesting! You will receive a new password shortly. If we accept the meaning given, it was already known about anyway. I Love Quran. The expansion of the universe is the increase of the distance between two distant parts of the universe with time. This also goes along with the context of the verse after, which again speaks about Gods ability/power to spread out the earth: And We have spread out the (spacious) earth: How excellently We do spread out! became clear to Muslim scholars that the details mentioned with regards to the Some interpretations based on tafsir books. It was common knowledge that meteors containing iron fell to earth from space. But the point is that Allah refers to a creation we are not able to create, we didn't witness, but only are able to observe the result. It is the same argument skeptics hear from Christians and proponents of Nostradamus. The Arabic word in the term which is translated into English as it is We Who are steadily expanding it, comes from the root word and is an Active participle of this root. What Islamic scholars say after they critically examine the Quran, Hafs Quran is Unreliable & Untrustworthy - Qira'at Conundrum - Episode 14, Scientific Miracles in the Quran Debunked. This root occurs 32 times in the Quran, in six derived forms. "(The Qur'an, 51:47)"Verily, the Hour is surely coming. Many Muslims claim that God revealed scientific facts in the Quran long before modern science discovered them.
Dawson County Arrests 2021,
Jackson, Mn Jail Roster List,
Articles Q
